How to Dispute a Google Review: A Doctor's Guide

March 19, 2024

A single negative review, warranted or not, can significantly impact your practice's online reputation, but what do you do when you come across a review that's unfair, misleading, or downright false? This is where the art of disputing a Google Review comes into play. Let's discuss the steps and strategies you need to know to manage your online reputation effectively.


Understanding the Impact of Google Reviews


Before we get into the nitty-gritty, it's important to understand why Google Reviews matter so much. These reviews are often the first impression potential patients have of your practice. They can influence decisions, shape perceptions, and ultimately determine whether someone chooses your services over another provider's. Research indicates that 84% of people trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations, underscoring their role in the decision-making process.


Reviews provide a narrative about your services, staff, and patient experiences. A positive review can highlight the strengths and uniqueness of your practice, while a negative one can raise doubts, even if it doesn't reflect the reality of your services. Importantly, it's not solely the star ratings that matter but also the substance of the reviews themselves. Detailed testimonials can offer insights into what it's like to be treated by you, often covering aspects such as bedside manner, office environment, wait times, and communication skills. This depth of information can play a crucial role in whether a potential patient opts for your services or looks elsewhere.

 

Given this context, managing your Google Reviews isn't merely about mitigating damage from negative feedback but also about leveraging positive reviews to build a trustworthy and appealing online presence.


When to Dispute a Google Review


Not all negative reviews should be disputed. Sometimes, constructive criticism can provide valuable feedback for improving your services. However, if a review is false, misleading, contains prohibited content, or violates Google's review policies, it's time to take action.


How to Dispute a Google Review


  1. Evaluate the Review: Before anything else, make sure the review in question actually violates Google's review policies. This can include spammy content, off-topic reviews, or personal information being shared.
  2. Respond Publicly: While you're working on disputing the review, it's a good idea to respond publicly in a professional manner. This shows other potential patients that you take feedback seriously and are proactive in resolving issues.
  3. Flagging the Review: If you've determined the review violates Google's policies, you can flag it directly from your Google My Business account. Click on the review you wish to dispute and select 'Flag as inappropriate'. This sends the review to Google for evaluation.
  4. Provide Detailed Information: If the situation requires further action, be prepared to provide detailed information to Google supporting why the review should be removed. This could include evidence that it's fake, violates privacy, or other relevant information.
  5. Follow-up: Google doesn't always act swiftly in these cases, so it may require some patience and possibly follow-up inquiries on your part.


Managing Your Online Reputation Proactively


While dealing with negative reviews is part of managing your online reputation, adopting a proactive approach can mitigate their impact. Encouraging satisfied patients to leave positive reviews can drown out the occasional negative voice. There are ethical ways to encourage this feedback without violating any guidelines or seeming pushy.


Leveraging Professional Help


Sometimes, managing an online reputation feels like a full-time job in itself. Clinician Box specializes in helping healthcare professionals manage their online presence, deal with negative reviews, and build a positive online reputation. Consider scheduling a strategy session with us. Our team of experts can provide personalized advice and strategies tailored to your specific needs and challenges. Don't let a few negative reviews tarnish years of hard work. Take control of your online reputation today.

January 30, 2026
How to Carefully Leverage AI in Healthcare Marketing Key Takeaways: ● AI in healthcare marketing starts with having the right data. ● When your competitors are using AI too, it takes strong guidelines and oversight for better ROI. ● At its worst, poorly used AI can lead to poor patient outcomes or even mistrust of the entire medical community. AI healthcare marketing promises to fix (nearly) every problem you face, whether it’s creating excellent content, generating crisp, clean graphics, or posting more regularly. However, AI in healthcare marketing is somewhat different from other industries. More than just a loss of reputation, wrong or irrelevant information can betray your patient’s trust in the field on a much deeper level.
Two people pointing at a computer screen displaying charts and graphs, discussing data analysis.
January 8, 2026
Stop drowning in data. Learn how to track the right marketing metrics, spot trends, and turn analytics into actionable insights to refine your strategy and drive real results.
AI in Healthcare Marketing
December 30, 2025
Learn how to leverage AI in healthcare marketing without risking patient trust. Get key steps for ethical use, data management, and creating compliant, effective campaigns that build your practice's reputation.
girl-setting-up-an-Email-List
December 17, 2025
Stop patient no-shows and 'ghosting.' Learn how to build an email list for your medical practice to improve patient communication, retention, and care.
HIPAA compliant content
December 4, 2025
Avoid costly breaches and build patient trust. Learn how to align your healthcare website's content and marketing with HIPAA rules. Get actionable tips for using de-identified content, auditing tools, and maintaining compliance without sacrificing growth.
content writing for healthcare practices
November 25, 2025
Learn how to align your medical practice's content with business goals to drive patient inquiries & bookings. Get a proven framework for high-ROI healthcare content strategy.
Marketer checking SEO,GEO & AIO
November 6, 2025
Is your practice ready for the next shift in SEO? Learn how GEO and AIO are changing patient acquisition. Clinician Box explains the evolution and your new action plan.
A man is sitting at a desk in front of a bunch of computer monitors looking at the marketing trends.
August 1, 2025
Discover the top healthcare marketing trends for 2025, including AI-driven personalization, local SEO optimization, and patient engagement strategies to grow your practice. Learn how to leverage short-form video, chatbots, and HIPAA-compliant marketing to attract and retain patients.
GEO Targeting concept
June 20, 2025
Discover how Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) transforms healthcare content strategy—ensuring AI like ChatGPT cites your expertise. Learn why physicians must adapt to medical GEO now to combat misinformation, boost visibility, and engage patients. Get actionable GEO optimization tips for AI-friendly content.
A tablet is open to a google search page.
May 21, 2025
Search Engine Optimization (SEO) has always been a moving target. Just when you think you've got it figured out, Google changes the rules again. Their latest updates aren't just small tweaks - they're fundamentally changing how search works. If you want your website to stay visible, you need to understand what's coming and how to adapt.
Show More

Take control of your online medical presence with Clinician Box! 

LET US HELP!